Thursday, October 6, 2016

“Empowerment or Abandonment”

Dean Dad has some insightful things to say about the ways different students react to different teaching approaches.

At the time, I felt confident in my overall philosophy, even if not necessarily in every single moment.  My job, as I saw it, was to create students who didn’t need professors.  At some level, I still believe that.  After all, when they graduate, they won’t have professors or t.a.’s around to decode things for them. 

From a distance, though, and in a very different institutional setting, I see a different possible interpretation of what I was doing.  Students with some cultural capital, and some academic confidence, could respond to that sort of teaching as a challenge, and some did.  Students without much cultural or academic capital could read it as indifference, and respond in kind.  That wasn’t what I intended, but intentions only get you so far.  If you’re a student with a relatively fragile sense of belonging in college in the first place, someone refusing to help you could look like a sign of hostility, or as confirmation that you don’t belong. 

The teaching style with which I started was the one I had seen quite a bit as a student.  I cobbled together a general theory behind it and went with it.  And at the flagship research university where I was in grad school, it worked tolerably well.  The students generally were well-enough prepared in traditional ways that they could work with it.  They didn’t always like it, but they could work with it.

Upon moving to a very different setting, it took a while to make the adjustment. 

I was reminded of that recently in visiting a class of entering students and hearing them describe their own frustration at some institutional practices designed to empower them.  What was supposed to convey empowerment instead made them feel abandoned. 

The challenge in designing systems for students is in accurately picturing different students encountering it for the first time.  Does being told “it’s on the website” come as a relief -- “I don’t have to wait for you!” -- or as evasion (“why won’t you help me?”)?  Given the diversity of the student body at most community colleges, the answer is “yes.” 

The long-term answer (!), I think, is in conceiving of all of our processes as part of the learning experience.  Even if the eventual goal is to foster empowered, self-directed learners, some need more initial guidance than others to get there.  And that’s okay; people start in different places.  I can just imagine if I hired a personal trainer who started with “okay, let’s warm up with a five mile run.”  Um, no.  Not gonna happen.  Maybe someday, but not right out of the gate.  Replace “five mile run” with “five page paper” or “FAFSA workshop,” and the same principle holds.  If you don’t start within shouting distance of where people are, you’ll lose them.

7 comments:

  1. Thanks for sharing such a valuable info.
    waiting for your another post…..!!
    Packers And Movers Hyderabad

    ReplyDelete
  2. Intuit concocted a far reaching retail answer for all business segments QuickBooks Point Of Sale. It is accessible for both work area and in addition online business. QuickBooks Point Of Sale accompanies special cases includes as in following stock, constant reports, and so forth. This easy to use programming is anything but difficult to manage yet under a few conditions client may run over a few Errors which may go about as an obstacle in their work. Quickbooks POS Error 175305 is essentially an investigate store trade error.

    ReplyDelete
  3. There will always be winners and losers, and I think many of these probably do have quite a diverse range of material, with a common thread running through them. This is how I think of Oracle Code, a diverse collection of subjects loosely woven together by an Oracle thread.
    Oracle SQL/PLSQL course

    ReplyDelete
  4. BIG DATA Technologies provides you with a state of the art software which combines modern GPU technology (Graphic Processing Units) with the best practices in today’s Big Data platforms, providing up to 100x faster insights from data.
    Bigdata Training in Chennai OMR

    ReplyDelete
  5. The following is a rundown of fixes for QuickBooks Payroll Error 15276. You should not have to take after every one of them to determine the issue. For QBW32.exe Do a Windows Search, which is situated in C:\Program Files\Intuit\QuickBooks. for QBW32.EXE in Windows 7, you have to seek. tap the connection for More Results in the Windows Search segment, If QBW32.EXE does not come up amid starting hunt. tap on Computer symbol, On Next Screen, (Windows will run a pursuit in your PC).

    ReplyDelete
  6. Call Our Quickbooks Enterprise Support Phone Number 1888-557-6950 is offer the service: QuickBooks Error, QuickBooks Backup, QuickBooks Software Install & Update, QuickBooks Drivers, QuickBooks Enterprise, QuickBooks Payroll, QuickBooks Premier, QuickBooks Pro Adviser, QuickBooks Troubleshoot, multi use mode issue or any kind of technical & functional issue.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Many people wish to inquire the Norton Antivirus Technical Support Number to take care of the issues concerning the program. Regardless that, individuals will Functioning know-how enhanced get in connection with the quantity which often can result in a longer keep out time on your own cell phone. Additional details This is actually the Norton Antivirus Customer Service Helpline Number just in case you are aiming to try and do set up, activation or updating within the software package offers you. Visit Here: https://www.ihelplinenumber.com/Norton-Antivirus-Customer-Support/

    ReplyDelete